Nostalgia

5th Avenue

$3.00

Indulge in some sweet nostalgia with the 5th Avenue chocolate bar. Its delicious flavor and...

Sold Out

Annabelle Abba Zabba Peanut Butter Chocolate

$3.00

Satisfy your cravings and shake things up with the Annabelle Abba Zabba Peanut Butter Chocolate!...

Annabelle's Abba-Zabba

$3.00

Satisfy your sweet tooth with Annabelle's Abba-Zabba bar! Indulge in the delicious combination of chewy...

Sold Out

Annabelle's Rocky Road

$3.00

Indulge in a playful treat with Annabelle's Rocky Road. Experience the delightful combination of rich...

Sold Out

Annabelle's Rocky Road Dark Chocolate Sea Salt

$3.00

Satisfy your sweet and salty cravings with Annabelle's Rocky Road Dark Chocolate Sea Salt bar....

Assorted Gumballs

$4.99

Get ready for a pop of flavor with our Assorted Gumballs! With a variety of...

Assorted Jordan Almonds

$4.99

Indulge in the classic taste of traditional assorted Jordan almonds. These timeless treats are sure...

Bazooka Throwback Mini Wallet

$1.50

Get ready to blow away your boring old wallet with the Bazooka Throwback Mini Wallet!...

Big Hunk

$3.00

Satisfy your sweet tooth with Big Hunk candy - a "big hunk" of deliciousness! This...

Big League Chew Blue Raspberry

$3.00

Hit a home run with Big League Chew Blue Raspberry! This chewy bubble gum packs...

Big League Chew Cotton Candy Bubble Gum

$3.00

Score a home run with Big League Chew Cotton Candy Bubble Gum! This playful bubble...

Big League Chew Grape Bubblegum

$3.00

Swing for the fences with Big League Chew Grape Bubblegum. This grand slam gum packs...

Big League Chew Original Bubble

$3.00

Step up to the plate with Big League Chew Original Bubble gum! This classic gum,...

Big League Chew Softball Slammin' Strawberry

$3.00

Get ready to hit a home run with Big League Chew Softball Slammin' Strawberry! With...

Big League Chew Sour Apple Bubblegum

$3.00

Step up to the plate with Big League Chew's Sour Apple Bubblegum! This chewy treat...

Big League Chew Watermelon Bubble Gum

$3.00

Swing for the fences with Big League Chew Watermelon Bubble Gum! This pack of gum...

Bit-O-Honey

$4.99

Indulge in sweet nostalgia with Bit-O-Honey. This classic treat will transport you back in time...

Black & Red Berries

$4.99

Satisfy your sweet tooth with our Black & Red Berries! These chewy, crunchy, and fruity...

Black Cow

$3.00

Indulge in a tasty treat with our Black Cow caramel chocolate! This nod to nostalgia...

Bubble Jug Tropical Fruit Bubble Gum

$3.00

Introducing Bubble Jug Tropical Fruit Bubble Gum - a deliciously nostalgic treat for your taste...

Bubblegum Cigarettes

$2.25

Get ready to blow away your friends with Magic Color Bubblegum Cigarettes! These fun treats...

Butterscotch Buttons

$4.99

Indulge in these classic butterscotch candies that will have your taste buds doing a happy...

Candy Cigarettes

$2.25

Indulge your sweet tooth with Candy Cigarettes - a playful spin on old-fashioned candy sticks....

Caramel Apple Pops

$0.60

Get the best of both worlds with Caramel Apple Pops! These old fashioned lollipops feature...

Charleston Chew Chocolate Bar

$3.00

Indulge in a playful treat with the Charleston Chew Chocolate Bar! With a satisfyingly chewy...

Charleston Chew Strawberry Bar

$3.00

Get ready to chew on some serious deliciousness with the Charleston Chew Strawberry Bar! Made...

Chick-o-Stick King Size

$3.00

Indulge in the regal crunch of Chick-o-Stick's King Size treat! Made with the iconic chick-o-stick...

Chick-O-Stick Nuggets

$4.99

Indulge in nostalgia with these bite-sized Chick-O-Stick Nuggets! Crunchy and peanut buttery, these old-time candies...

Chocorock

$4.99

Indulge in a nostalgic trip down memory lane with Chocorock, the playful chocolate rocks that...

Claey's Cherry Drops

$4.99

Get your taste buds dancing with Claey's Cherry Drops! These old-fashioned cherry hard candies will...

Claey's Lemon Drops

$4.99

Satisfy your sweet tooth and add some zing to your day with Claey's Lemon Drops!...

Claey's Sour Apple Drops

$4.99

Indulge in Claey's Sour Apple Drops - handcrafted, old fashioned candies bursting with the tangy...

Creme Savers Strawberry & Creme Rolls

$3.00

Indulge in nostalgia with Creme Savers Strawberry & Creme Rolls! Enjoy the creamy strawberry and...

Crows

$3.50

Calling all candy connoisseurs! Our Crows black licorice gum drop candy is a must-try for...

Sold Out

Cry Baby Sour Mini Drinks

$6.50

Get ready for a mouth-puckering experience with Cry Baby Sour Mini Drinks! These sour wax...

Cup O Gold

$3.00

Indulge in nostalgia with Cup O Gold, the ultimate throwback treat. This delightful cup oozes...

Fun Dip Sour

$2.50

This nostalgic Fun Dip is the perfect treat for any candy expert. With a new...

Giant Chewy SweetTarts

$3.00

Indulge in a playful treat with Giant Chewy SweetTarts! These oversized, chewy SweetTarts will satisfy...

Hotlix Cinnamon Toothpix

$2.00

Get your nostalgia fix with Hotlix Cinnamon Toothpix! These toothpicks will take you back to...

Jaw Breakers

$4.99

Satisfy your sweet tooth with our classic 1 inch Jaw Breakers. Reminiscent of childhood memories,...

Sold Out

Look! Candy Bar

$2.99

Indulge in the quirky and delicious Look! candy bar! Made with high-quality ingredients, this 1.375...

Mary Jane

$4.99

Indulge in nostalgia with Mary Jane candy! This quirky treat boasts old-fashioned flavors of rich...

Necco Chocolate Wafers

$3.00

Indulge in a roll of Necco Chocolate Wafers! These tasty wafers are made with rich,...

Necco Original Candy Wafers

$3.00

Indulge in the classic sweetness of Necco Original Candy Wafers! Perfect for a quick and...

Nik L Nip Wax Bottles (4 Pack)

$3.50

Indulge in some sweet nostalgia with Nik L Nip Wax Bottles. This 4 pack of...

Nik-L-Lips Wax Bottles

$3.75

Get your lips poppin' with Nik-L-Lips Wax Bottles! These TikTok-tastic treats come in a 4...

Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles

$6.50

Take a trip down memory lane with Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles! This nostalgic 8 pack of...

Reggie! Bar

$3.50

Indulge in a dose of nostalgia with the Reggie! Bar. This quirky chocolate bar is...

Sort by

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Search our store

Nostalgia

Filters

Recently Viewed Products

Stay up to date with all fashion news and exclusive offers

Let’s get in touch

Links

For Customers

Shopping Cart

Stay up to date with all fashion news
and exclusive offers