Nostalgia

Filters

Availability
Price
From $
To
To $

Cup O Gold

Regular price $3.00
Sale price $3.00 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in nostalgia with Cup O Gold, the ultimate throwback treat. This delightful cup oozes...

Giant Chewy SweetTarts

Regular price $3.00
Sale price $3.00 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in a playful treat with Giant Chewy SweetTarts! These oversized, chewy SweetTarts will satisfy...

Hotlix Cinnamon Toothpix

Regular price $2.00
Sale price $2.00 Regular price
Unit price
Get your nostalgia fix with Hotlix Cinnamon Toothpix! These toothpicks will take you back to...

Limited Edition Cheerwine Goo Goo Cluster

Regular price $3.00
Sale price $3.00 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in a one-of-a-kind treat that brings together two iconic flavors in perfect harmony. This...
Sold Out

Look! Candy Bar

Regular price $2.75
Sale price $2.75 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in the quirky and delicious Look! candy bar! Made with high-quality ingredients, this 1.375...

Mary Jane

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in nostalgia with Mary Jane candy! This quirky treat boasts old-fashioned flavors of rich...

Mini Jaw Breakers

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price
Satisfy your sweet tooth with our classic Jaw Breakers. Reminiscent of childhood memories, these nostalgic...

Necco Chocolate Wafers

Regular price $3.00
Sale price $3.00 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in a roll of Necco Chocolate Wafers! These tasty wafers are made with rich,...
Sold Out

Necco Original Candy Wafers

Regular price $3.00
Sale price $3.00 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in the classic sweetness of Necco Original Candy Wafers! Perfect for a quick and...

Nik L Nip Wax Bottles (4 Pack)

Regular price $3.50
Sale price $3.50 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in some sweet nostalgia with Nik L Nip Wax Bottles. This 4 pack of...

Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles

Regular price $7.00
Sale price $7.00 Regular price
Unit price
Take a trip down memory lane with Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles! This nostalgic 8 pack of...

Ouch! Bubble Gum

Regular price $4.75
Sale price $4.75 Regular price
Unit price
Experience a blast from the past with Ouch! Bubble Gum, a retro-inspired treat shaped like...

Passion Fruit Retro Sours

Regular price $5.75
Sale price $5.75 Regular price
Unit price
Dive into nostalgia with Passion Fruit Retro Sours—a tangy blast from the past that'll make...

Peanut Butter Goo Goo Cluster

Regular price $3.00
Sale price $3.00 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in the ultimate peanut butter experience with our Goo Goo Cluster—a decadent combination of...

Pecan Goo Goo Cluster

Regular price $3.00
Sale price $3.00 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in the ultimate candy lover's dream with our Pecan Goo Goo Cluster. This iconic...

Raspberry Retro Sours

Regular price $5.75
Sale price $5.75 Regular price
Unit price
Dive into a burst of tart raspberry bliss with Raspberry Retro Sours—the classic candy that...

Razzles Original

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price
Experience the nostalgia and delight of Razzles Original candy, the classic treat that transforms from...

Red Apple Retro Sours

Regular price $5.75
Sale price $5.75 Regular price
Unit price
Bite into nostalgia with Red Apple Retro Sours—tart, tangy candies that capture the bold flavor...

Reggie! Bar

Regular price $3.50
Sale price $3.50 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in a dose of nostalgia with the Reggie! Bar. This quirky chocolate bar is...

Retro Sours Citrus

Regular price $4.75
Sale price $4.75 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in the newest version of the beloved Altoids Sours - now available in a...

Retro Sours Mango

Regular price $4.75
Sale price $4.75 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in nostalgia with our candy expert-approved Retro Sours Mango. This new version of the...

Retro Sours Tangerine

Regular price $4.75
Sale price $4.75 Regular price
Unit price
As a candy expert, there's nothing quite like the latest release of Retro Sours Tangerine!...

Root Beer Barrel

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price
Colombina Root Beer Barrel Hard Candy is free from gluten and GMOs and tastes like...

Satellite Wafers

Regular price $4.00
Sale price $4.00 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge your sweet tooth with Satellite Wafers! These classic candy wafers are filled with deliciously...

Satellite Wafers Sour Blue Raspberry

Regular price $4.00
Sale price $4.00 Regular price
Unit price

Sizzling Cinnamon Jawbreaker

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in a blast from the past with our Sizzling Cinnamon Jawbreaker. These old fashioned...

Smarties Mega Double Lollies

Regular price $1.75
Sale price $1.75 Regular price
Unit price
Wanna double your fun? Get our Smarties Mega Double Lollies twice the size, twice the...

Sour Razzles

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price

Sour Satellite Wafers

Regular price $4.00
Sale price $4.00 Regular price
Unit price

Sugar Free Chick O Stick Bites

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price
Atkinson's crafts these Chick-O-Stick retro candy favorites with peanut butter, toasted coconut, and Splenda® to...

The Original Goo Goo Cluster

Regular price $3.00
Sale price $3.00 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in a timeless classic that's been delighting candy enthusiasts since 1912. The Original Goo...

Tootsie Pops

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge your sweet tooth with Tootsie Pops, the classic candy with a delicious chocolate center....

Tootsie Roll Assorted Flavors

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price
Indulge in the playful variety of Tootsie Roll! This assorted pack offers a range of...

Tootsie Roll Chocolate

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price

Wacky Wafers

Regular price $3.50
Sale price $3.50 Regular price
Unit price

Watermelon Retro Sours

Regular price $5.75
Sale price $5.75 Regular price
Unit price
Dive into nostalgia with Watermelon Retro Sours—the classic candy that brings back childhood memories with...

Wax Bottles

Regular price $3.75
Sale price $3.75 Regular price
Unit price
Experience a blast from the past with our classic Wax Bottles, a nostalgic candy favorite!...

Whatchamacallit

Regular price $3.50
Sale price $3.50 Regular price
Unit price
Introducing the Whatchamacallit - a delicious chocolate treat that will leave your taste buds guessing!...

Zagnut

Regular price $3.50
Sale price $3.50 Regular price
Unit price
Satisfy your cravings and tickle your tastebuds with Zagnut, a wild and wacky combination of...
Sort by
  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old

Recently Viewed Products